If you’re trying to write a character who is unlike you, or whose identity is different from your own, the answer might be on your nightstand.
A couple of years ago, a simple question went out on r/writers: what are you struggling to write right now? One writer, who has since deleted his account, replied with a single word: “Women.”
Asked who he was reading, he explained that another Redditor had recommended Flannery O’Connor, since he read work primarily written by men. O’Connor is arguably the most masculine female short story writer there is, and that, in a nutshell, was his problem. There was a lot to talk about there.
His follow-up question: he had heard of Harper Lee, who wrote To Kill a Mockingbird. Was she any good?
People began to pile on at that point, though a few commenters stayed focused. Some recommendations held steady through the noise: Bastard Out of Carolina by Dorothy Allison, Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston, and The Awakening by Kate Chopin. He replied that he was into Southern Gothic literature, apparently a subgenre of horror, largely because of Cormac McCarthy, an influence he admitted was very blatant in his own writing. That was why he had been recommended O’Connor.
It’s not just a man writing a woman. It’s difficult to write a character outside of our own gender, race, class, culture, sexuality, ability, or even generation. With efforts like the “own voices” movement, writers have been told recently that it might even be unethical to write in the perspective of someone who is outside of their identity, especially if they get it wrong. It’s great to prioritize queer voices writing queer characters, disabled writers writing disabled characters, and so on. The literary world needs such diversity! But we also believe that writers are allowed to use their imagination to write characters outside of themselves.
This is where reading comes in. Narrow reading flattens characters because what you read is the raw material for what you write. Whether he knew it or not, this writer revealed something that happens to a lot of people: they get into a rut with their point of view and with the art they expose themselves to.
That rut becomes a feedback loop. It gets tighter and tighter. The work improves within itself, yet it also becomes bland, monotone, and all one way, because all of the input is monotone. If all you consume is musicals, the monotone is that it is all musicals. What comes out always ends up feeling derivative.
Broadening your taste is actually very difficult. People are naturally creatures of habit.
The trouble starts when reading outside your identity becomes an assignment, because you have been told your women characters are two-dimensional, or that your characters from other backgrounds don’t ring true.
Take the Reddit writer’s case: maybe you know a woman has to be in your book because you need a love interest, and she’s got to be hot. Maybe you know women have to be in your book because women read. (Ideally, no writer is thinking about the audience to that degree while writing.)
Reading under those conditions feels a little like eating your broccoli. Intentionally exposing yourself to things you wouldn’t otherwise read, and sticking with something despite an immediate aversion, is good practice. Just be careful not to spoil a book for yourself because you feel you have been forced.
Generation is part of identity, too. Some older writers, for example, may force themselves to read debut novels by young, contemporary writers. They approach the slightly post-puberty, twenty-two-year-old profound mind with a general disgust, bitterness, and fatigue. But that’s a bad way to go into anything. Give the book a real shot, and assume there is something to get out of it.
It goes both ways. Around the time of alt lit, plenty of younger readers balked at the idea of War and Peace. They saw the traditional literary canon as lame. They wanted to read books made from G-chats instead. If you’d told them they had to read War and Peace, they might have done so, kicking and screaming and hating it the whole time.
The point is, you can’t assign someone a broader reading palate. It has to be a desire that bubbles up from within.
If reading feels like homework, borrow a lesson from the toddler at the dinner table. Being introduced to different flavors, different tastes, and different writers is a process. It is pretty rare to find children who eat everything and anything from the get-go. Research finds that most toddlers have to be exposed to something repeatedly, eight to fifteen times, before they get into it. It takes that many tries to figure out whether you actually like something.
The same is true in every way for writers. Open-mindedness is hard. Exposure to uncomfortable things is hard. Some people are convinced that open-mindedness is an inherent trait: some people are naturally open-minded, others naturally closed-minded, and there is nothing to be done about opening one’s mind. But in fact, it’s a skill, just like anything else.
A more open-minded reader is, without a doubt, a more open-minded writer. What would your open-mindedness as a writer bring to your book-in-progress? Or to your future readers?
If you’d like personalized help with broadening your reading taste, understanding what your characters are missing, or making a plan to finish your novel draft, book a free consultation with a Hewes House writing coach or developmental editor.